| Next Mission |
|---|
| Return 2 — "Heart" |
Return 1: Invitation Summary
| Return 1 Walkthrough Chart | |
|---|---|
| 1 | Obtain the Cauldron Lake Map and follow the investigator, Casey. |
| 2 | Talk to the Deputy Sheriff and proceed beyond the fence. |
| 3 | Meet Sheriff Thornton at the General Store and go to the Crime Scene. |
| 4 | Examine the body and learn how to use the Case Board. |
| 5 | Collect 3 clues from the body. |
| 6 | Place 3 clues on the Case Board. |
| 7 | Obtain clues at 6 locations. |
| 8 | Progress with reasoning on the Case Board. |
| 9 | Obtain new clues through profiling. |
| 10 | Check the lakeshore and examine the blocked path. |
| 11 | Progress with reasoning on the Case Board. |
| 12 | Talk to the sheriff and obtain the shortcut key. |
| 13 | Use the shortcut key to open the door and drive back to Bright Falls in the car. |
| 14 | Talk to Breaker at the Diner entrance in Bright Falls. |
| 15 | Talk to Booker and others inside the diner. |
| 16 | Obtain clues through profiling and receive a necklace from Booker. |
| 17 | Head to the sheriff's office. |
| 18 | Examine Nightingale's body. |
| 19 | Progress with reasoning on the Case Board. |
| 20 | Enter the light and recover health. |
| 21 | Obtain a Pistol and defeat enemies. |
| 22 | Talk to Casey and obtain the Manuscript. |
| 23 | Read the manuscript and progress with reasoning on the Case Board. |
| 24 | Explore the town and move to the car. |
Return 1: Invitation Walkthrough
[1] Obtain the Map and follow Casey.
After the tutorial, the story progresses from Saga Anderson's perspective. First, obtain the Cauldron Lake Map and follow Casey down the path.
[2] Talk to the Deputy Sheriff and proceed beyond the fence.
As you proceed down the path, you'll have a conversation event with the deputy sheriff. Bold dialogue options must be selected to progress the story, so if you want to follow the story in detail, choose the regular-weight dialogue options to continue the conversation. After talking with the deputy, you can proceed beyond the fence.
[3] Meet the Sheriff and go to the Crime Scene.
As you proceed beyond the fence, Saga's "Mind Place" function will be unlocked during your journey. Don't use the Mind Place at this point—follow Casey to the general store to meet Sheriff Thornton. After the conversation, follow Thornton to move to the crime scene.
[4] Examine the body and learn how to use the Case Board.
After arriving at the crime scene, examine the body on the table. When you examine the body, you'll obtain the Key Image "Cauldron Lake Murder Scene," then go to the Mind Place and place it on the Case Board to progress the investigation.
Case Board Control List
| Control Buttons | |
|---|---|
Cursor Movement | Camera Movement |
Check Key Images/Clues | Place Clue |
Zoom In | Zoom Out |
Change Content in Mind Place | |
When playing as Saga, you can organize and reason through the Case Board in the Mind Place each time you obtain a clue. On the Case Board, the basic procedure is "select the active Key Image or clue with D-Pad Up → place it on the corresponding item with the X button," so remember this.
[5] Collect 3 Clues from the Body.
After placing the Key Image "Cauldron Lake Murder Scene" on the Case Board, you can obtain clues from the body. Position the cursor on the body's magnifying glass and collect 3 clues.
[6] Place Clues on the Case Board.
| Question | Clues to Place |
|---|---|
| Consistent with Prev. Murders? | ・Large trauma to the chest ・Cargo rope used to restrain victim ・Heart found near the victim's body |
Place the 3 clues found on the body onto the Case Board's reasoning items. Once all 3 are placed, Saga will progress the reasoning, and new items "Victim?" and "Murderer?" will appear.
[7] Obtain Clues at 6 Locations.
After "Victim?" and "Murderer?" appear on the Case Board, investigate the area around the body at the crime scene again for clues. Note that you can talk to Casey once you've finished organizing "Murderer?"
[8] Progress with Reasoning on the Case Board.
| Question | Clues to Place |
|---|---|
| Victim? | ・Thornton's testimony ・Casey's testimony |
| Murderer? | ・Blood scattered throughout the table ・Multiple footprints |
| Premeditated or Accidental? | ・Tripod found near the body ・Cooler and beer bottles placed nearby |
Once you've collected a reasonable number of clues, progress with reasoning on the Case Board. Organize "Murderer?" and "Victim?" in order, and once both are complete, "Premeditated or Accidental?" will appear, and clues about the tripod and cooler box will become active.
[9] Obtain New Clues through Profiling.
When you organize the "Premeditated or Accidental?" item on the Case Board and progress the reasoning, the profiling function will be unlocked. Through profiling, you can enter the hearts and minds of suspects and victims to obtain clues. Obtain clues from "Missing Person" and "Ritual Murder."
[10] Place Clues on the Case Board.
| Question | Clues to Place |
|---|---|
| Where did the victim come from...? | Nightingale came from Cauldron Lake. |
Once profiling is complete, you'll automatically transition to the Case Board. Place the clue obtained from Nightingale's profiling onto "Where did the victim come from...?"
[11] Check the Lakeshore and examine the Blocked Path.
Follow Casey and examine the blocked path to obtain a clue and manuscript. Obtaining the manuscript will trigger a cutscene and earn you the trophy "Not the End."
Read the Manuscript in profiling to obtain a clue. After that, the "Manuscript" feature will be added to the Mind Place and you can check it anytime.
[12] Progress with reasoning on the Case Board
| Question | Clues to Place |
|---|---|
| Where did the victim come from...? | ・The footprint disappeared ・The footprint emerges from beneath the rocks |
| Is there something else? | ・Something is hidden within Nightingale. ・As I read it, these words feel like a message. Someone is toying with them. |
After reading the manuscript, progress with reasoning on the Case Board. Placing the clues about Nightingale and the manuscript onto "Is there something else?" will advance the reasoning.
[13] Talk to the Sheriff and obtain the Shortcut Key.
After finishing the reasoning, return to the crime scene with Casey. Talk to the sheriff to obtain the shortcut key.
- Use the shortcut key to open the door and return to the car
Use the obtained shortcut key to open the 2 doors and return to the car. When you get in the car, you'll move to Bright Falls, so if you plan to explore, do so before getting in the car.
[14] Talk to Breaker at the Diner Entrance.
After arriving in Bright Falls, talk to Breaker at the diner entrance. After talking to Breaker, you'll be able to enter the diner. Also, when you arrive in Bright Falls, don't forget to obtain the map from the bulletin board.
[15] Talk to Booker and others inside the Diner.
After talking to Breaker, enter and talk to Booker and his associates. If you want to follow the story in detail, choose the regular-weight dialogue options for your conversations with Booker and others.
[16] Obtain clues through Profiling.
After finishing the conversation with Booker and others, perform profiling in the Mind Place. Profile "Tree Cult" and "Cauldron Lake" to obtain clues. Once profiling is complete, you can obtain a necklace from Booker.
How to Complete Cauldron Lake Murder Investigation
| Question | Clues to Place |
|---|---|
| What is the murderer's profile? | Booker stated that multiple individuals wearing deer masks repeatedly shouted while "stabbing the man with a knife repeatedly." |
After Booker's profiling, select the "Cauldron Lake Murder Case" file on the Case Board and place the clue to reveal the investigation completion Key Image. Additionally, "Tree Cult" is added to the case, and the Tree Cult Case Board becomes available for reasoning.
[17] Head to the Sheriff's Office.
After the diner event, follow Breaker to the sheriff's office. Before heading to the medical examiner's room in the morgue, obtain the map from the reception desk.
When you enter the employee lounge in the sheriff's office, Collect the Koskela Brother Commercial: "Adventure Tours". The obtained video can be viewed on the TV in the Mind Place.
[18] Examine Nightingale's Body
Position the cursor on 5 magnifying glasses on the body and collect 5 clues. Once all 5 clues are collected, the Case Board for the "Cauldron Lake Murder" case becomes available for reasoning.
[19] Progress with Reasoning on the Case Board.
| Question | Clues to Place |
|---|---|
| Words related to ritual? | ・Unclear writing beneath the victim's skin ・Indecipherable words on the heart |
| What is the cause of death? | ・The chest is open - something is visible inside ・Victim's bruises and defensive wounds ・Swelling at the joints indicates prolonged water exposure |
Select "Cauldron Lake Murder" from the cases in the Mind Place's Case Board and add the Key Image "R. Nightingale's Autopsy." Placing any clue onto "What can be learned from the body...?" will allow you to proceed with "Words related to ritual?" and "What is the cause of death?"
[20] Enter the Light and recover Health.
After organizing the Case Board and pressing the button displayed on the body, an event will progress, the body becomes a monster, and it will attack you. Once you can act, first enter the light to recover your health.
[21] Obtain a Pistol and Defeat the Enemy.
After recovering health, wait for the monster to head to the left entrance, then turn on your flashlight and proceed to the right entrance to obtain the Pistol. After obtaining it, shoot the pursuing monster several times to progress the story.
[22] Talk to Casey and obtain the Manuscript.
After the battle with the monster, talk to Casey who is nearby. If you want to follow the story in detail, choose the regular-weight dialogue options. After the conversation, obtain and read the manuscript on the morgue floor to obtain a clue.
[23] Read the Manuscript and progress with Reasoning on the Case Board.
| Question | Clues to Place |
|---|---|
| Cult symbol...? | Cult necklace with a triangular symbol |
| Cult psychology...? | The followers wore deer masks |
| Cult purpose? | ・Cult murder victims became monsters ・Casey: The Tree Cult performs rituals to create monsters |
| Cult ritual? What is it like? | ・Victim's body/organs covered in text. Manuscript discovered inside the chest ・Nightingale was the only victim to become a monster |
Read the obtained manuscript and progress the reasoning on the "Tree Cult" Case Board. Note that the Tree Cult is unlocked when you obtain the Key Image for completing the "Cauldron Lake Murder Case" investigation, so it's good to finish the murder case investigation first.
[24] Explore the Town and move to the Car.
After finishing the reasoning, explore the sheriff's office and Bright Falls town as you make your way to the car. When you get in the car, you'll move back to Cauldron Lake, and Return 1 "Invitation" will be complete.
Before getting in the car, enter the diner to grab the Koskela Brothers Commercial: "Ahma Beer," watchable later on the TV in the Mind Place. You can also chat with Rose the waitress here. The conversation wraps up after you've selected both dialogue options.
Return 1: Invitation Collectibles
Koskela Brothers Commercials
In Return 1, you can obtain 2 types of Koskela Brothers Commercial. The obtained advertisements can be viewed on the TV in the Mind Place anytime.
Adventure Tours
Ahma Beer
Radio
The radio "Together Into Darkness" can be obtained by defeating the attacking body, and the cutscene will play. Once the cutscene finishes or is skipped, you obtain it. The obtained radio can be checked anytime in the Mind Place.
Manuscripts
In Return 1, you can obtain 4 types of manuscripts revealing future events. The obtained manuscripts can be viewed in the Mind Place's Manuscript tab.
Lunch Boxes
In Return 1, you can obtain 2 types of lunch boxes related to the case "Alex Casey's Lunch Box." The obtained manuscripts can be viewed in the Mind Place's Cases tab.
Cult Stashes
Related Guides
List of Story Chapters
Return
| Return Walkthrough List | |
|---|---|
Return 1 — "Invitation" | Return 2 — "Heart" |
Return 3 — "Local Girl" | Return 4 — "No Chance" |
Return 5 — "Old Gods" | Return 6 — "Scratch" |
Return 7 — "Summoning" | Return 8 — "Deerfest" |
Return 9 — "Come Home" | |
Initiation
| Initiation Walkthrough List | |
|---|---|
Initiation 1 — "Late Night" | Initiation 2 — "Casey" |
Initiation 3 — "Haunting" | Initiation 4 — "We Sing" |
Initiation 5 — "Room 665" | Initiation 6 — "Return" |
Initiation 7 — "Mask" | Initiation 8 — "Zane's Film" |
Initiation 9 — "Gone" | |