This guide covers the Hey Arnold! mission in Chapter 1. Your choice here affects Jason's Criminal Profile but does not lock you out of any missions or endings.
Quick Answer: Spare Arnold
Spare Arnold is the recommended choice. Neither option changes the story, but sparing him gives Jason a Restrained Criminal Profile rating, while killing him gives a Hardened rating. Brian accepts the outcome either way.
| Kill Arnold | Spare Arnold | |
|---|---|---|
| Criminal Profile | Hardened | Restrained |
| Story Impact | None | None |
| Brian's Reaction | Accepts | Accepts |
| Next Mission | Island Dreams | Island Dreams |
| Can Be Reversed? | No | No |
Hey Arnold! Mission Walkthrough
The Hey Arnold! mission triggers early in Chapter 1 when Brian Heder sends Jason and Cal to deal with his former business partner Arnold, who has been causing problems.
Step 1: Meet Brian and Get the Job
Brian tells Jason that Arnold has been talking to the wrong people and needs to be dealt with. Accept the mission to begin tracking Arnold down.
Step 2: Chase Arnold
Arnold spots you and flees. The pursuit starts as a vehicle chase with Arnold's men firing at you from motorcycles, then transitions into a foot chase through residential alleys and along wooden boat docks toward the waterfront.
Step 3: Corner Arnold at the Dock
The chase ends at a dock on Maroon Key. Arnold is cornered at the edge of the jetty with nowhere left to run. He drops to his knees and begs for his life, saying he wants to leave the criminal life behind.
Step 4: Make Your Choice
You now have two options: Kill Arnold or Spare Arnold. If you do nothing and wait, Arnold will eventually jump into the water and swim away (same outcome as sparing him).
What Happens If You Kill Arnold
Choosing to kill Arnold means Jason shoots him. This gives Jason a Hardened Criminal Profile rating. The mission ends, and Jason reports back to Brian that Arnold won't be a problem anymore.
Brian then introduces Jason to treasure hunter Kenton Rees, and the next mission, Island Dreams, unlocks. The main story continues identically regardless of this choice.
For more on Kenton's missions, see the Treasure Diving Guide.
If you use an unsuppressed weapon, nearby NPCs may call the police. Consider your surroundings before pulling the trigger.
What Happens If You Spare Arnold
Choosing to spare Arnold means Jason lowers his weapon. Arnold jumps into the water and swims away. Jason tells Brian that "Arnold's going to keep his mouth shut," and Brian accepts the decision without complaint.
This gives Jason a Restrained Criminal Profile rating. The story continues to the Island Dreams mission with Kenton Rees, exactly the same as the kill path.
Criminal Profile Impact
The Criminal Profile system in GTA 6 tracks how Jason and Lucia handle situations throughout the story. Each choice shifts the profile toward either Hardened or Restrained.
| Choice | Profile Shift |
|---|---|
| Kill Arnold | → Hardened |
| Spare Arnold | → Restrained |
| Do Nothing (timeout) | → Restrained |
The Criminal Profile works like an honor system. It accumulates across all story decisions, so a single choice here won't define your entire profile. For more details on how the system works, see the Criminal Profile System Explained guide.
Does This Choice Affect the Ending?
No. The Hey Arnold! choice does not change which ending you get. GTA 6's endings are determined by decisions made much later in the story. For a full breakdown, see How Endings Work.
The Arnold decision is one of the earliest moral choices in the game, but it only contributes to your overall Criminal Profile score rather than gating any content.
Next Steps
- Continue with the next mission, Island Dreams, where Brian introduces Jason to treasure hunter Kenton Rees
- Explore Kenton's treasure-diving questline in the Treasure Diving Guide
- Learn how the Criminal Profile system shapes your playthrough in our Criminal Profile System Explained guide
- See all story decisions and their outcomes in the All Missions List